I bought this at Sephora months ago, so I’m not sure if they’re still selling these sets, but this one came with (from l-r) Hedonist, New Wave, Jealous and Little Black Dress. These aren’t as opaque as the lip tars. Hedonist is a purplish pink, New Wave is basically magenta, Jealous is a vibrant red and Little Black Dress is not as scary black as it looks. Little Black Dress works well at adding dimension when used under the other colors.
These are vibrant colors, but since they’re more stain and less gloss, they work well even for day makeup looks. I found Stained Gloss easier to apply than the Lip Tars. They seem to have better staying power, too, although it may not be as obvious since they are much more sheer. Whether you like the Lip Tars or not, I suggest you try these.